Whiskey Glass Performance Review: Glencairn vs Norlan vs Rauk

---

Introduction

In my previous post, I shared in-depth reviews of the Glencairn glass, Norlan glass, and Norlan Rauk Heavy Tumbler. Now, in this separate post (Part 2, if you will), we have the exciting opportunity to experience these glasses side by side and witness their performance firsthand. While initially intended as part of the previous review, I decided to give this comparison its own dedicated space, as it can definitely hold its own as a standalone exploration.

For this glass performance review, it was only fitting to have a bourbon alongside. Today, I decided to go with the beloved Woodford Reserve Double Oaked. This beauty right here happens to be one of my absolute favorite daily sipper bottles. One of the reasons I picked it out is because of its lower proof point. And also because it’s just plain delicious.

Initially, I was leaning towards the cask strength route, with something like Old Ezra 7 or Jack Daniel’s Single Barrel Barrel Proof. Those bad boys bring a full-bodied experience to the nose and palate. That would mean I would be able to really put these glasses to the test and find out if their design truly allows me to dissect and unravel the intricate aromas and flavors.

But here’s the catch, my friends. As you might guess that because they’d be cask strength, getting to the point of being heavily shlammered would likely come much quicker, and considering we have three glasses to review, that means three cask strength pours.

For added personal context, when I enjoy cask strength expressions, my usual sweet spot is just one pour (depending on the proof) to get me in the right zone. Two pours can take me slightly above my normal buzz (again, depending on the proof). Anything beyond that, we’re talking facial numbness and a comatose state. I’m not about that life, folks. I’m here to savor and appreciate my drams responsibly and in moderation. Am I professional sommelier or scientist? Nope. I’m not those either. Just a normal dude who enjoys bourbon and giving an honest normal-dude opinion, you feel me?

Hence, Woodford Reserve Double Oaked. Back to the show.

Mini Bourbon Review: Woodford Reserve Double Oaked

It’s important to keep in mind here that I’m not putting so much emphasis on my tasting notes of the bourbon, but more so on how I’m arriving at those notes based on the glass that I’m drinking it from. This is a whiskey glass comparison/performance review after all, so I want to be sure to keep that front and center. So sit tight, grab a glass (preferably one we’re reviewing), and let’s dive right into it.

Glencairn

• Nose: The aromas of maple syrup and sweet corn greet the senses, with a deep inhale revealing subtle hints of alcohol that are gentle and non-overpowering. The aromas are well-focused and concentrated.
• Palate/Finish: Flavors reminiscent of Snickers, honey, and caramel unfold on the palate. The finish is reminiscent of sweet creme brulee and lingers with notes of mocha chocolate. There’s also a subtle, crisp alcohol kick.

The thin lip of the glass allows the whiskey to glide effortlessly onto my palate, enhancing the overall drinking experience. However, it’s worth noting that in social settings, tilting your head back slightly to take a sip may disrupt the flow of conversation, as you momentarily break eye contact. Despite this minor consideration, the Glencairn glass still enables you to fully appreciate the whiskey from nose to palate to finish.

Norlan Glass

• Nose: Slightly less muted, but I can still get a nice full sense of the aromas. Surprisingly, there is no hint of alcohol burn, even with deep and deliberate inhalation. It’s practically non-existent, allowing for a worry-free nosing experience without any discomfort. As I circulate my nose around the rim, I detect delightful notes of creamy, buttery caramel, movie popcorn.
• Palate/Finish: What can I say. It’s the same good old WRDO (damn, this is delicious). The way the whiskey rolls out the glass naturally feels different. The lip is noticeably thicker, almost double the thickness of the Glencairn’s lip. I’d say nearly double the thickness, and this particular aspect has been a point of discussion among many reviews, sparking debates and observations about the tactile experience of drinking from this glass.

Whatever science is going on in the design of the Norlan, it’s working. Not getting a sniffle of ethanol when nosing. Norlan does mention that the way it has those little four grooves, divets, err chevrons is what they’re calling them, is what aerates the whiskey. So as a result, you’re getting less alcohol, and more whiskey aroma goodness.

Norlan Rauk Heavy Tumbler

• Nose: Surprisingly, I’m still able to get a good nosing outta the Rauk glass. I think that might have to do with the design of the upper portion of the glass. Instead of the sides shooting directly upward, the rim caves somewhat inward, taking on similar functionality as the Norlan glass. There is a wider circumference overall so I’d expect the aromas to be much more muted. However, you need to keep in mind that if/when you’re are using this glass, you shouldn’t be expecting a competition level nosing experience.
• Palate/Finish: The whiskey rolls off more like the Glen. The rim is thinner than the Norlan, but thicker than the Glen. So this is a nice balance for taking the functionality of the two. I can’t tell any difference in flavor profile

I never fail to feel like a boss when holding this glass. It seriously has a nice hefty badonkadonk to it. It is weighty. Literally like a rock. This is a glass you whip out when you want to impress, when you want to look like a boss, when you want to chill… or maybe when you just don’t want to think about the whiskey, and just enjoy. Feel free to put a rock of ice in there too, because that’s what it was made for after all. Hell, you can even use it for fancy cocktails, and it’ll look just as fly.

Overall Thoughts

There’s no clear “winner” in this case. I’m sorry to bust your bubble if that’s what you were looking for. But, I can give you my personal recommendations on which glass to use in certain situations.

Glencairn

• Serious deep thinking and analysis — Whether you’re a whiskey connoisseur, a collector, or simply someone who enjoys diving into the intricacies of whiskey, the Glencairn glass is an ideal choice. Its shape and design help capture and showcase the whiskey’s aromas, flavors, and color.
• Home tasting — If you’re hosting a whiskey tasting session at home or enjoying a personal whiskey journey, the Glencairn glass enhances the overall experience. It allows you to savor the aromas and flavors of various whiskies, helping you develop a deeper understanding and appreciation for each pour.
• Training — For those studying or teaching about whiskey, the Glencairn glass is an essential tool. Its standardized design ensures consistency in nosing and tasting, making it easier to compare and discuss different whiskies.

Norlan Glass

• Casual enjoyment — Whether you’re sipping your favorite whiskey after a long day or enjoying a leisurely evening with friends, the Norlan glass adds a touch of elegance and enhances the overall drinking experience.
• Getting those Instagram banger shots — The Norlan glass is a visually stunning piece of glassware, making it an excellent choice for whiskey collectors or those who appreciate displaying their whiskey collection in style.
• Gifting — Due to its sleek design and reputation, the Norlan glass makes a thoughtful and impressive gift for whiskey enthusiasts or those who appreciate fine glassware.

Norlan Rauk Heavy Tumbler

• Whiskey on the rocks: If you enjoy your whiskey with a few ice cubes or a single large ice sphere, the Rauk Heavy Tumbler is an excellent choice. Its sturdy construction and weighted base make it a reliable glass for enjoying your whiskey over ice.
• Cocktails and Mixology: The Rauk Heavy Tumbler’s stylish design and substantial feel make it a great option for serving whiskey-based cocktails. Whether you’re mixing an Old Fashioned, a Whiskey Sour, or your own unique concoction, the Rauk Heavy Tumbler will not fail to showcase your drink in style.
• Relaxed whiskey enjoyment: If you’re simply looking to unwind and enjoy your favorite whiskey in a casual setting, the Rauk Heavy Tumbler is a go-to choice. Its substantial weight and comfortable grip create a comforting and relaxing whiskey-drinking experience.

Additional Images

---

Dram Japan Newsletter
Get email notifications when new posts come out!